Authorities Management Over the Circulation of Info: Lord Sumption Speaks Out In opposition to the On-line Security Invoice within the Newest Episode of Legislation Pod UK

Creator: Rosalind English

The On-line Security Invoice is at the moment making its manner by way of the Home of Commons, having reached the report stage in July. The invoice’s idea of “authorized however dangerous” is controversial, and has attracted criticism from excessive locations, not least of all former Supreme Court docket choose Jonathan Sumption. Lord Sumption joins Rosalind English on this episode to debate the issues concerned in defining this type of hurt and the ideas of “misinformation and disinformation” within the Invoice.

Lord Sumption worries in regards to the “sheer randomness” of the method for figuring out authorized however dangerous materials, and factors out that the web is totally huge; the “scale and pace at which materials is added to it each second of our lives is breathtaking”. The one manner, he says, that this may be managed is by means of algorithms. However they’re incapable of detecting nuance or irony. They’re blunt devices. If you find yourself making use of this type of approach to materials at this scale, you might be sure to get a really massive variety of false positives.

“So you’ll lose an infinite quantity of completely acceptable materials, materials that’s not solely authorized however not dangerous.”

Hearken to extra in Episode 169.

Legislation Pod UK is offered on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Audioboom, FM Participant, ListenNotes, Podbean, iHeart, Public Radio, Deezer or wherever you hearken to our podcasts.


This piece has been reposted from the UK Human Rights Weblog with permission and thanks. The weblog submit is an commercial for episode no. 169 of Legislation Pod UK during which the topic is mentioned intimately with Lord Sumption.